History of paleontology in Germany

Chapter 5: Deconstructing Chimeras & Debating Organic Origins (1690s–1740s)



U N D E R     C O N S T R U C T I O N 






The observations and collections described in the previous part provided an increasingly substantial body of evidence, yet the origin and significance of many fossil remains remained uncertain.
During the late 17th and 18th centuries, naturalists in the German-speaking lands gradually moved beyond supernatural explanations and the interpretation of fossils as mineralogical curiosities or lusus naturae (freaks of nature). Through anatomical comparison with living organisms, careful examination of fossil remains, and investigation of their geological context, they began to approach fossils as empirical evidence of ancient life and the Earth's history.
The work of Leibniz and other naturalists contributed to this shift, helping to lay the foundations for a more systematic study of fossils and the development of palaeontology as a scientific discipline.

The Quedlinburg “Unicorn” and an Early Fossil Reconstruction in Germany (1704)


Fountain of Klagenfurt on stamp of Austria 1968
Fountain of Klagenfurt on stamp of Austria 1968 MiNr.: 1256, Scott: 696.
One of the first documented attempt to reconstruct a prehistoric animal in Europe dates to around 1590, when a monumental Lindwurm (dragon) sculpture was carved in Klagenfurt, Austria. Its head was reportedly modeled on a fossil skull discovered near Klagenfurt around 1335, which survives and is still on display at the Landesmuseum für Kärnten.
In a study published in 1840, the same year that the first adhesive postage stamp, known today as the Penny Black, was issued in Great Britain, paleontologist Franz Unger (1800–1870) identified the skull as belonging to an Ice Age woolly rhinoceros, which he called Rhinoceros tichorhinus Cuvier (now Coelodonta antiquitatis), rather than to a mythical dragon.

The earliest surviving published reconstruction of a fossil animal in Germany appeared in 1704, when Michael Bernhard Valentini included a reconstruction of the Quedlinburg “unicorn” in his Museum Museorum. In the third volume, Chapter 30, entitled Von dem wahren und gegrabenen Einhorn (“On the true and fossil unicorn”), Valentini presented several forms associated with the unicorn tradition, including a reconstructed Unicornu fossile based on the remarkable fossil discovery near Quedlinburg.
Valentini identified the specimen as a Unicornu fossile and stated that the skeleton depicted had previously been found near Quedlinburg and subsequently described and illustrated by Johann Meyer, an astronomer and municipal official of Quedlinburg.
Unicorns represented by Michael Bernard Valentini, published in 1704
Michael Bernhard Valentini, portrait engraving by Andreas Matthäus Wolfgang after Christoph Labhart, 1701. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, RP-P-2022-4364. Public domain. Rijksmuseum collection.
Michael Bernhard Valentini (1657–1729) was a German physician, physicist, and naturalist born in Giessen.
He studied medicine at the University of Giessen and received his medical degree there in 1686. After travelling through France, the Netherlands, and England, he returned to Giessen, where he became professor of physics in 1687 and professor of medicine in 1697. He maintained extensive scholarly contacts and was a member of several learned societies, including the Academia Naturae Curiosorum (later the Leopoldina), the Berlin Academy of Sciences, and the Royal Society of London. In 1728 he was appointed imperial personal physician.

His best-known work, the extensive Museum Museorum, was first published in Frankfurt am Main in 1704 and subsequently expanded, with the final volume appearing in 1714. It brought together information on natural specimens, medicines, minerals, plants, animals, curiosities, and collections, incorporating reports and observations from scholars, physicians, travellers, and collectors. The work reflects the increasingly international exchange of natural knowledge in the late 17th and early 18th centuries.

Unicorns represented by Michael Bernard Valentini, published in 1704
Unicorns represented by Michael Bernard Valentini in Museum Museorum, published in 1704.
The accompanying illustration presented four forms associated with the unicorn tradition:
  • Unicornu officinale – the "medicinal unicorn horn", represented by a narwhal tusk;
  • Unicornu marinum – the sea unicorn, represented by a narwhal;
  • Unicornu fictitium – the fictitious unicorn, represented as the traditional horse-like animal with a single horn;
  • Unicornu fossile – the fossil unicorn, represented by the reconstructed Quedlinburg skeleton.
Valentini discusses the origins and medicinal properties attributed to different forms of the unicorn tradition. He explains that the Unicornu officinale used in pharmacies was the tusk of the narwhal, then regarded as a type of sea unicorn. These tusks were brought from Greenland by traders along with products such as seal skins and blubber.
He questions the existence of the traditional four-legged, horse-like unicorn, noting the large number of supposed "unicorn horns" found in treasuries, churches, and apothecaries despite the animal's supposed rarity. He also questions the exaggerated medicinal powers attributed to these horns, particularly their alleged ability to counteract powerful poisons.
Valentini then discusses the Unicornu fossile, describing fossil teeth and horns found in various regions, including the Harz Mountains, Hesse, the Palatinate, and Württemberg. He notes that their nature was disputed: some regarded them as petrified remains of animals or giants, while others considered them natural stone formations. Valentini mentions that Dr. Johann Bauhin supported the latter interpretation in his Tractatus de Unicornu Fossili, but leaves the question open for further investigation.

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz and the Changing Interpretation of Fossils (1716/1749)

In 1685, Ernst August, Duke of Brunswick-Lüneburg-Calenberg, commissioned his court historian Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz to write a history of the House of Brunswick to advance the family's dynastic ambitions.
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz on stamp of Germany 1926
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz on stamp of Germany 1926, MiNr: 395, Scott: 360.
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646–1716) was a German polymath whose work encompassed mathematics, philosophy, natural science, history, and diplomacy.
He is best known for his independent development of calculus, carried out around the same time as Isaac Newton, as well as for his contributions to logic and philosophy.
His interests, however, extended far beyond mathematics.
He was fascinated by the history of the Earth and by the evidence preserved in rocks and fossils.
He investigated minerals, geological formations, and natural processes, seeking to explain the development of the Earth through observation and reason.

In connection with this project, Leibniz expanded his studies of the natural history and geology of the region. His interest in fossils, however, dated back considerably earlier; by the late 1670s, he was already considering the origin of fossil remains. His meeting with the Danish naturalist Nicolaus Steno in 1678 also contributed to his developing interest in fossils and the geological history of the Earth.
Between 1691 and 1693, as a preface to his planned history of the House of Brunswick, Leibniz drafted Protogaea. Originally conceived as a natural history of the region around Lower Saxony, it developed into a much broader investigation of the formation and history of the Earth, including rocks, minerals, fossils, and geological processes.
Title page of the Protogaea book of Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
Title page of the Protogaea by Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, written in Latin.
Like René Descartes in his Principia philosophiae (1644), Leibniz proposed that the Earth had developed from an initially molten state through natural physical processes. Unlike Descartes, however, he sought to reconstruct the Earth's history from observations of rocks, minerals, strata, fossils, caves, and mining excavations. He also drew on the work of Nicolaus Steno, whose studies had established the importance of fossils and geological strata as evidence of the Earth's past.

Leibniz argued that many fossils were the petrified remains of actual living organisms rather than lusus naturae (“sports of nature”). A similar view had been advocated much earlier by the French naturalist Bernard Palissy in his Discours admirables (1580), in which he recognized many “petrified” objects as the remains of once-living organisms. Leibniz emphasized the striking similarity between fossils and living animals, noting that different species of fish could be recognized from their stone impressions. Fossils therefore became evidence of a buried natural history that could help reconstruct the Earth's past.

Leibniz's position on fossils had developed over time. In an earlier manuscript he had apparently questioned their organic origin, partly for theological reasons, but by the time of Protogaea he accepted the organic nature of many fossil remains. At the same time, he did not accept the transformation of one species into another. Although he considered the possibility that some creatures might have adapted to changing environments, he rejected the idea that terrestrial animals had evolved from aquatic ancestors, arguing that this conflicted with Scripture.

Leibniz also proposed that the Earth's surface had been profoundly transformed by slow natural processes. The forces operating within the Earth, together with the action of fire and water, had gradually shaped its rocks, strata, and landscapes. In this respect, Protogaea presented the Earth as a dynamic body whose present condition could be understood through its geological history.
The Monochrome Proofs cards of Evolution of the Earth issue of Niuafoʻou 1989
6 of 10 stamps from "Evolution of the Earth" issue of Niuafoʻou (Tonga) 1989, MiNr.: 139-144, Scott: 108-113.
Although Protogaea was never published in complete form during Leibniz's lifetime, parts of it appeared in print, beginning with an abridged version in Acta eruditorum in 1693. Leibniz continued to revise and expand the manuscript as new observations and information became available. Although Protogaea was never published in complete form during Leibniz's lifetime, the manuscript was eventually edited and published posthumously in 1749 by the German historian, jurist, and librarian Christian Ludwig Scheidt (1709–1761), then librarian and archivist in Hannover. The edition included 12 engraved plates.
Plates with fossil images from Protogaea of Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, published in 1749
Plates with fossil images from Protogaea of Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, published in 1749

The final Plate, XII, combines two fossil subjects.
The upper image shows a mammoth molar from Thiede near Stederburg, identified in the Latin caption as Dens animalis marini Tidae prope Stederburgum e colle limoso effossi (“Tooth of a marine animal excavated from a loamy hill near Stederburg”). The reference to a “marine animal” reflects the difficulty early naturalists faced in explaining large fossil remains found far inland.
The lower image depicts the reconstructed skeleton from the Quedlinburg find, with the caption Figura Sceleti prope Qvedlinburgum effossi (“Figure of a skeleton excavated near Quedlinburg”).
Leibniz reported that he had received a written account and a drawing of the discovery and incorporated them into the manuscript. The report and original drawing appear to have originated with Johann Meyer of Quedlinburg. Leibniz and the engraver Nicolaus Seeländer later modified and completed the reconstruction. The engraving became the best-known historical representation of the Quedlinburg “unicorn”.


Modern Interpretation of the Quedlinburg “Unicorn”

Quedlinburger Unicorn comparison of reconstructions, iedrich, C. G. (2021)
Quedlinburger Unicorn comparison of reconstructions from:
(a) Valentini, 1714, (b) Leibniz 1749, (c) Rust, 2002, (and (d) new interpretation).
The “Unicorn” seem to have been composed of (e,f) two different Eemian interglacial Ice Age megamammals such as the straight-tusked elephant Palaeoloxodon antiquus (“horn” = tusk), and the horses Equus ferus fossilis/przewalskii (skull, front legs, anterior vertebral column and sternal bones), which explains the “horse-like” Unicorn reconstruction. (g) Unicornus fossilis illustration as a horse-like animal with narwhale horn (from Topsell, 1658 "Courtesy of Special Collections, University of Houston Libraries. UH Digital Library") and (h) new illustration based on the reconstruction of (by George “Rinaldino” Teichmann)
The figure is from Diedrich, C. G. (2021). Unicorn “holotype” skeleton from the Late Pleistocene spotted hyena den site Sewecken-Berge (Germany). Acta Zoologica, 00, 1–70. >https://doi.org/10.1111/azo.12392
While both Valentini's and Leibniz's reconstructions of the unicorn were based on the same lost fossil discovery, they reflect very different creative approaches.
Valentini's 1704 illustration is a raw, blocky, and direct copy of the original crude sketch by local official Johannes Meyer, serving as a simple archival record of a strange local curio. In contrast, Leibniz's 1749 plate is a highly stylized and dynamic transformation. Leibniz smoothed out the disjointed bone fragments, giving the creature a more mammalian, upright posture and a sweeping horn to present it as a cohesive, biologically plausible animal structure.

After the publication of the book, several scientists scrutinized this "Quedlinburg Unicorn" reconstruction and noted that its strange skull and fragmented bones heavily resembled those of a rhinoceros. However, because the field of historical biogeography was still in its infancy, these early researchers were at a total loss to explain how a tropical rhinoceros could have ever existed in the cold climate of Germany.

Today, paleontologists agree that the fossil skeleton is a composite created from the bones of multiple different Ice Age animals. Modern analysis demonstrates that the fossil configuration is a chimeric composite assembled from separate megafauna elements:
  • The massive shoulder blades and leg bones of a woolly mammoth (Mammuthus primigenius)
  • The skull of a woolly rhinoceros (Coelodonta antiquitatis) or a horse
  • The straight horn is probably a narwhal (Monodon monoceros) tusk — a young narwhal has a straight and smooth surface, without spiral grooves. Others suggest it may have been a tusk from a straight-tusked elephant, Palaeoloxodon antiquus, or even a tusk of a woolly mammoth if the tusk was broken up badly enough that the people who reassembled it had the freedom to make it any shape they wanted.
  • The origins of the other unicorn bones, such as the ribs, remain unclear.
Skeleton of woolly mammoth on imprinted personalized stamp of Germany 2015 Woolly rhinoceros on stamp of Belgium 2018 Adult and young narwhal on stamp of USSR 1971
Skeleton of woolly mammoth on imprinted personalized stamp of Germany 2015 Woolly rhinoceros on stamp of Belgium 2018, MiNr.: 4845, Scott: 2872. Adult and young narwhal on stamp of USSR 1971, MiNr.: 3962, Scott: 3936.



The Altdorf Vertebrae and the Interpretation of Fossil Remains (1692–1708)

Johann Jakob Scheuchzer on the cachet and commemorative postmark of  Switzerland 1977 Ichthyosaur vertebrae from book of Johann Jakob Scheuchzer, published in 1708
Johann Jakob Scheuchzer on the cachet and commemorative postmark of Switzerland 1977 Ichthyosaur vertebrae from book of Johann Jakob Scheuchzer, published in 1708.
In 1692, Johann Jakob Scheuchzer (1672–1733), a Swiss physician and naturalist who studied at the University of Altdorf near Nuremberg visited the so-called Gallows Hill (Galgenberg) with a fellow student, who discovered a rock containing articulated vertebrae. Scheuchzer recovered several of the specimens and later incorporated them into his fossil collection.
In his Piscium querelae et vindiciae, published in Zürich in 1708, Scheuchzer illustrated two of the vertebrae and interpreted them as fossilized human remains, associating them with the Biblical Flood. The book's copper-engraved illustrations are attributed to the Swiss engraver Johann Heinrich Huber (1677–1712), who helped document these early fossil discoveries.

Johann Jacob Baier
Johann Jakob Baier (1677-1735). Image credit: Wikipedia.
Ichthyosaur vertebrae from book of Johann Jakob Baier, published in 1708
Ichthyosaur vertebrae (Nr. 32, 33) from book of Johann Jakob Baier, published in 1708.
Platypterygius ichthyosaur on commemorative postmark of Germany 2005
Platypterygius ichthyosaur on commemorative postmark of Germany 2005
In the same year, Johann Jakob Baier (1677–1735), professor of medicine at the University of Altdorf, published his Oryctographia Norica, in which he illustrated other vertebrae from Altdorf. Baier rejected Scheuchzer's interpretation, identifying them instead as the vertebrae of a large marine fish. His interpretation was closer to the modern understanding, although the fossils are now known to belong to ichthyosaurs - marine reptiles that lived about 250 million to 90 million years ago.
The correspondence between Scheuchzer and Baier represents one of the earliest documented scientific debates over the origin and identity of fossil vertebrate remains. The Altdorf specimens are also among the earliest documented records of Mesozoic marine reptiles from Germany.


Burgtonna and the Identification of Fossil Elephant Remains


In 1695, workers digging sand near Burgtonna unearthed the massive remains of a large prehistoric animal, including an enormous tusk measuring about 2.4 meters in length, several large molars, and numerous skeletal bones. Reflecting the popular folklore of the era, the local excavators initially misidentified the strange, tusk as the horn of a legendary "fossil unicorn" (unicornu fossile). The unusual scale of the remains immediately attracted widespread public attention.

Friedenstein Castle in Gotha on stamp of Germany 2018
Friedenstein Castle in Gotha on stamp of Germany 2018, MiNr.: 3367, Scott: 3015.

Various explanations were proposed, including the possibility that they represented a biblical giant or a lusus naturae ("sport of nature"). The Collegium Medicum of Gotha became institutionalized in the debate by direct order of Duke Friedrich II of Saxe-Gotha-Altenburg. Because specialized fields like paleontology and geology did not yet exist, state-appointed medical doctors were considered the highest academic authorities on organic anatomy and chemical mineralogy. Upon learning of the bizarre discovery, the Duke ordered the massive bones to be brought to Friedenstein Castle and tasked his sovereign board of court physicians with issuing an official report.

Wilhelm Ernst Tentzel
Wilhelm Ernst Tentzel (1659-1707).

Eager to defend the era's mainstream scientific consensus—which held that the Earth's climate had remained completely static since creation—the council aggressively rejected the notion that tropical megafauna could have ever existed in Germany. They argued instead that the bones were of mineral origin, growing directly within the soil in a manner reminiscent of the conclusions reached by Johann Lorenz Bausch in 1666, some three decades earlier.

However, Wilhelm Ernst Tentzel (1659–1707), the ducal court historiographer of Saxe-Gotha-Altenburg, approached the discovery with a more systematic method. He compared each of the fossil bones with the corresponding skeletal elements of a modern elephant, drawing on the detailed anatomical description of a living elephant published by the Irish physician and anatomist Allan Mullen in 1682, as well as the classical observations of Aristotle and Pliny, and the structural insights of modern naturalist John Ray.

In 1681, an elephant that had previously been exhibited in London was taken to Dublin, where it died when its wooden shelter caught fire.
Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) on stamp of Bangladesh 1977
Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) on stamp of Bangladesh 1977, MiNr.: 101, Scott: 114.
The elephant had arrived in London in 1675, probably aboard a ship of the East India Company, although its exact origin and route to England are unknown. It was later taken to Ireland by the showman Mr Wilkins and exhibited in a wooden booth near the Custom House on Essex Street in Dublin. The elephant remained there until the booth caught fire on 17 June 1681.
The Irish physician and anatomist Allan Mullen (1653-1690) examined and dissected the carcass, making detailed observations of its skeleton and internal anatomy. His account was sent to the Royal Society and published in 1682 as An Anatomical Account of the Elephant Accidentally Burnt in Dublin. The dissection, described by the Royal College of Surgeons as the first dissection of an elephant in the British Isles, provided European scholars with an important anatomical reference for later comparisons with fossil elephant remains.
In his 1696 treatise, Epistola de sceleto elephantino Tonnae nuper effosso ("Letter concerning the recently excavated elephant skeleton of Tonna"), Tentzel argued from anatomical similarities that the Burgtonna remains belonged to an elephant rather than representing a lusus naturae ("sport of nature") or the remains of a legendary giant. The regularity of the layers in which the skeleton was embedded, he further argued, showed that the remains could not have been placed there by human agency.
Tentzel therefore considered that the presence of an elephant in Thuringia required a general cause, which he explained through the Biblical Flood. Although this interpretation remained firmly rooted in the intellectual and theological framework of the late 17th century, his use of comparative anatomy represented an important step toward the systematic identification of fossil vertebrates.

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz on stamp of Germany 1980
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz on stamp of Germany 1980, MiNr: 1050, Scott: 1329.

Tentzel's systematic methodology quickly drew the attention of Europe's learned elite, involving Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz directly in the international discussion via an intense scientific correspondence.
Intrigued by the Thuringian discovery, Leibniz used Tentzel's meticulous notes to expand the geological and biological theories he was compiling for his own treatise, Protogaea. Remarkably, Leibniz noted to Tentzel that "changes have taken place in the elephants themselves" — suggesting that these ancient creatures were structurally better adapted to cold northern regions than their modern counterparts.
This profound insight provided early hints toward evolutionary adaptation, helping Leibniz bridge the conceptual gap between living species and the petrified monuments of nature.


Palaeoloxodon antiquus on stamp of Nevis 2005 Woolly mammoth (Mammuthus primigenius)  on stamp of Jersey 2010, with its molar on attached  label
Palaeoloxodon antiquus on stamp of Nevis 2005, MiNr: 2096, Scott: 1450c. Woolly mammoth (Mammuthus primigenius) on stamp of Jersey 2010, MiNr.: 1523, Scott: 1464, with its molar on attached label.
Today, the Burgtonna fossils are recognized as remains of the extinct straight-tusked elephant (Palaeoloxodon antiquus), which inhabited Europe during the Pleistocene, approximately 2.58 million to 11,700 years ago. They should therefore not be confused with the woolly mammoth (Mammuthus primigenius).

Tentzel's interpretation was not immediately accepted, however. The controversy surrounding the Burgtonna fossils illustrates the gradual transition from traditional explanations of unusual fossil remains toward interpretations based on anatomical comparison and geological evidence.

A second elephant skeleton was discovered near Burgtonna in 1799, only about 15 metres from the site of the famous 1695–1696 discovery. The skeleton was found in a compressed and bent position and occupied approximately 6 metres. Its two tusks were about 3 metres long and had fallen from their sockets. Although much of the material was fragile and several bones crumbled during excavation, portions of the lower jaw, large molars, tusks, and other bones were preserved and carefully described. By 1799, there was no longer serious doubt that the Burgtonna remains belonged to an elephant. The principal questions had shifted to the age of the animal and its place in the history of the Earth. The Burgtonna discoveries therefore marked an important transition from identifying fossil remains to investigating their geological age and the existence of extinct species.


The anatomical triumphs of Quedlinburg, Altdorf, and Burgtonna permanently broke the spell of the lusus naturae in the German-speaking lands, proving that fossils were the authentic, structural monuments of a dynamic earth history.
Yet, as the mid-18th century approached, resolving whether a fossil bone belonged to a modern elephant or an ancient marine reptile was no longer enough. The isolated case studies of local naturalists had amassed a chaotic mountain of organic data that desperately required global organization, systematic ordering, and a deeper exploration of cosmic time. The stage was now set for a broader European Enlightenment. In the chapters that follow, this narrative expands beyond regional excavations to track the grand synthesis of the natural world: from the visionary mineralogical and cosmological insights of Emanuel Swedenborg, to the revolutionary global taxonomy of Carl Linnaeus, and finally to the pioneering comparative anatomy of Petrus Camper and Georges Cuvier, whose work would transform these early debates over ancient monsters into the definitive science of extinction.




References


The "Unicorn" of Quedlinburg (The Magdeburg Unicorn)

Burgtonna and Wilhelm Ernst Tentzel

  • Susanne Friedrich (2025) Tentzel and the elephant in the room. Inconsistencies in the history of nature and history of humans (not) being discussed when ‘fossils’ were found in Thuringia in 1695, Annals of Science, 82:3, 351-380, DOI: 10.1080/00033790.2025.2483296
>

Personalities mentioned in the article

Johann Meyer
(1607–1665)
Michael Bernhard Valentini
(1657-1729)
Johann Jakob Scheuchzer
(1672–1733)
Johann Jakob Baier
(1677–1735)
Wilhelm Ernst Tentzel
(1659–1707)
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
(1659–1707)





Created 07.08.2026. Last update 05.11.2026