Thomas Jefferson the father of American Paleontology
Introduction: who is Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson (1743–1826) was an American Founding Father and the third President of the United States from 1801 to 1809. He was the primary author of the Declaration of Independence. Jefferson was the nation's first U.S. secretary of state under George Washington and then the nation's second Vice-President under John Adams.
|
| George Washington on imprinted and adhesive stamp on a letter sent from the Secretary of the Paleontological Society in 1936. |
Jefferson was a leading proponent of democracy, republicanism, and natural rights, and he produced formative documents and decisions at the state, national, and international levels.
Yet Jefferson was more than a statesman. In his own time, he was widely respected as a serious and capable man of science. His intellectual range was remarkable: a skilled mathematician and astronomer, he accurately calculated the solar eclipse of 1778 and proposed refinements to almanacs concerning the equation of time. He was knowledgeable in anatomy, civil engineering, mechanics, meteorology, architecture, and botany, and he read and wrote Greek, Latin, French, Spanish, and Italian. In addition to later contributions to ethnology, geography, and anthropology, Jefferson emerged as a pioneering figure in early American palaeontology. Despite this breadth of expertise, he modestly referred to himself as “an amateur” in science.
On April 29, 1962, President John F. Kennedy, at a White House dinner honoring American Nobel Prize winners, famously remarked:
I think this is the most extraordinary collection of talent, of human knowledge,
that has ever been gathered together at the White House — with the possible exception of
when Thomas
Jefferson
dined alone.
![]() |
![]() |
| Thomas Jefferson and others signers of the Declaration of Independence on FDC of USA from 1954 and 1968. | |
The Buffon Controversy (1760s–1780s)
![]() |
| Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon on stamp of France 1949 MiNr.: 874, Scott: B241. |
Buffon was not alone in promoting the idea of “degeneration” in the Americas. Several European observers circulated similar claims, suggesting that if European animals, such as horses, were left to roam freely in the New World, they would quickly decline in strength or size. Of course, Europeans did not realize that horses had been completely absent from the Americas for thousands of years before their arrival — the animals they observed were newly reintroduced by colonists, making the degeneration argument even more misleading.
Horses actually originated in North America millions of years ago, but they went extinct around 10,000 years ago. When Europeans arrived, there were no horses in the Americas, the animals they brought were a reintroduction of the species, not native populations. This makes earlier European claims that horses “degenerate” in the New World even more misleading.
![]() |
![]() |
| Prehistoric hourses Eohippus on a Maxi Card and FDC of USA 1996. | |
Thomas Jefferson regarded such claims as both scientifically unsound and politically insulting. In 1785, while serving as American minister to France, he published Notes on the State of Virginia, his most substantial scientific work. In it, he systematically challenged Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon’s theory of American “degeneracy”, compiling detailed measurements of American animals — bears, deer, panthers, and others — to demonstrate that many equalled or even exceeded their European counterparts in size and strength.
Collecting American Fauna and Expeditions
But Jefferson did not rely solely on printed argument. Determined to provide physical proof, he began collecting large American animal specimens, both living and extinct. He envisioned a systematic approach to document the continent’s fauna, seeking out the largest and most impressive examples to counter Buffon’s claims.![]() |
|
| Thomas Jefferson on stamps of USA. Above: 1904, MiNr.: 155, Scott: 324. Below: 1954 with perforation error, MiNr.: 654C, Scott: 1055. | |
![]() |
|
Through these combined efforts — field expeditions, specimen collection, and careful documentation — Jefferson sought to demonstrate that North America was home to animals as large, strong, and remarkable as any in Europe, providing tangible evidence to rebut the notion of New World “degeneration”.
While in Paris (1785–1789), as the United States ambassador to France, he arranged for the shipment of a complete moose skeleton and skin to Buffon. The specimen was enormous, reportedly requiring significant effort to transport across the Atlantic. When Buffon, who never visited America, examined the moose, he conceded that at least some of his claims about American animal size were mistaken, and later editions of Histoire naturelle softened aspects of his degeneracy thesis. This scientific exchange, part publication, part material demonstration, marked one of the earliest international debates in American natural history.
Most famously, he commissioned Meriwether Lewis and William Clark’s Corps of Discovery (1804–1806) to explore the newly acquired Louisiana Territory, following the Louisiana Purchase in 1803, which opened vast western territories to the United States. Jefferson regarded exploration as essential not only for political reasons but also for natural history. He instructed Meriwether Lewis and William Clark, leaders of the Lewis and Clark Expedition (the Corps of Discovery), to collect information on geography, flora, fauna, and especially large animals. Jefferson even hoped that living mastodons or mammoths might still roam the unexplored West.
Lewis and Clark collected specimens, made detailed drawings, and recorded measurements of animals both familiar and unknown to European science.
Big Bone Lick and Western Exploration
The fossil site at Big Bone Lick, Kentucky, was the most famous source of large fossil bones in North America during the 18th century and it is now widely regarded as the birthplace of American vertebrate paleontology. Among those particularly fascinated by the site was Thomas Jefferson.
|
| Benjamin Franklin and George Washington on definitive Stamps from 1922-1925 issue "Personalities and National Motifs", MiNr.: 260, 263; Scott: 552, 554, respectively. |
A 1740 map based on the expedition’s journal described the location as the "Place where the bones of many elephants were found by the army from Canada"".
Specimens from the site were soon sent to Europe for study. In France, Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon examined the fossils and was puzzled in particular by the teeth. Their pronounced cusps seemed to indicate a carnivorous animal, while the overall skeletal structure resembled that of a herbivorous elephant. Other naturalists, including Benjamin Franklin, were likewise intrigued. Franklin even speculated that “perhaps the climates were differently placed from what they are at present”, attempting to reconcile the presence of such enormous animals with the cooler North American environment.
Interest in Big Bone Lick extended to George Washington. In 1772 he received a large fossil tooth from John Connolly, a trader and land speculator active in the Ohio Valley. Writing to Washington after visiting the site, Connolly remarked, "I just stumbled upon the tooth I now present you with”. At the time, such remains were still commonly attributed to elephants, as the concept of extinction had not yet been fully accepted. Washington maintained a lifelong interest in these “mammoth” bones and later encouraged the gathering of further information about them.
![]() |
| Meriwether Lewis and William Clark on FDC of USA 2004 |
![]() |
| Meriwether Lewis and William Clark on stamp of USA 2004 MiNr.: 3834, Scott: 3854. |
Jefferson’s fascination with fossil discoveries was both scientific and national in character. Numerous fossils from Big Bone Lick were eventually sent to Jefferson. Many were forwarded to the American Philosophical Society, while select specimens were retained for what he described as “a special kind of Cabinet” at Monticello. He regarded these remains as prized elements of his natural history collection and as evidence of the grandeur of the American continent.
Interest in Fossils and the “Mammoth” (1780s–1790s)
While defending the vitality of American fauna, Jefferson became fascinated not only with living animals but also with fossil remains, particularly the enormous bones commonly called “mammoth” bones. These fossils, often found in the Ohio Valley and especially at Big Bone Lick in Kentucky, were widely discussed in scientific circles.At the time, it was unclear whether these bones belonged to elephants, unknown species, or animals still living in the unexplored American West. Jefferson refused to believe that any species could become extinct. He wrote:
Such is the economy of nature, that in no instance can be produced her having permitted any one race of her animals o become extinct.This conviction shaped his interpretation of fossil discoveries. Rather than seeing the bones as evidence of extinction, Jefferson speculated that living herds of “mammoths” might still roam the western territories beyond the Mississippi.
He actively sought fossil specimens, carefully cataloguing them when received. Many were sent to the American Philosophical Society in Philadelphia for study, while others he retained for his personal collection at Monticello.
![]() |
| Stamp Monticello on a cover of USA 1956, MiNr.: 669, Scott: 1047 on cover of Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists from Oklahoma, posted in 1958. |
Jefferson’s interest in fossils was also sparked by Indigenous oral traditions that spoke of great beings and ancient creatures revealed in the landscape. Native communities used their own terms and concepts — such as spirits or ancestral giants like the Lakota Unktehi, the Seneca Genonsgwa, and references to colossal “grandfathers” of familiar animals — to describe remains that Europeans found puzzling. European naturalists often interpreted these accounts through familiar reference points, translating them into terms like “giant elephants” or “hairy giants,” even though such animals were unknown in Indigenous histories. Jefferson approached these stories not as mere folklore, but as cultural clues pointing to the existence of extinct species.
Motivated by both scientific curiosity and the desire to challenge European assumptions about the New World, Jefferson organized and encouraged searches for fossil remains of these legendary creatures. He personally corresponded with local farmers, explorers, and naturalists, urging them to report or collect any large bones they found. Through these networks, mastodon fossils began to surface across Virginia and neighboring states.
![]() |
![]() |
| Mastodons on stamps of Marshall Islands 2009, MiNr.: 2518, 2522; Scott: 956a, 956e. | |
Mastodons were large, elephant-like mammals with long, curved tusks and molars adapted for browsing trees and shrubs rather than grazing. They could grow up to 3 meters long and weigh around 6 tons — truly the “giants” of North America. Jefferson meticulously measured, sketched, and documented each find, assembling a detailed record of these prehistoric giants.
A particularly important discovery occurred in 1796 near Tuscaloosa, Alabama, when a large collection of mastodon bones was uncovered along the Black Warrior River. The find included a nearly complete skeleton, which local collectors carefully excavated and sent to Jefferson for study. This discovery provided one of the first nearly intact mastodon skeletons in the United States and offered Jefferson a remarkable opportunity to study the anatomy of an extinct American giant firsthand.
|
![]() |
| Charles Wilson Peale with mastodon bones in his museum, as depicted on a U.S. Maxi Card and stamp (MiNr.: 684, Scott: 1064) from 1955 and in his painting "The Artist in His Museum". | |
In 1801, the artist and naturalist Charles Wilson Peale purchased the recovered bones and organized further excavations. Under the supervision of anatomist Caspar Wistar, Peale reconstructed the skeleton in Philadelphia, replacing missing elements with wood or papier-mâché. In December 1801, the mounted mastodon was unveiled before the American Philosophical Society and soon displayed to the public in Peale’s museum. The exhibition caused a sensation, and “mammoth fever” swept the young republic.
In February 1802, thirteen men, including John Isaac Hawkins, father of Benjamin Waterhouse Hawkins who built the first sculptures of prehistoric animals in 1854 in London, dined beneath the Peale mastodon at his Philadelphia museum. The dinner was organized by Rembrandt Peale, Charles Willson Peale’s son. After Charles Wilson Peale’s death in 1827, the museum declined, and much of its collection was sold. The famous Peale mastodon skeleton was eventually purchased by the German naturalist Johann Jakob Kaup in the 1850s and became part of the Hessisches Landesmuseum in Darmstadt, Germany, where it still resides today.
|
|
| Charles Wilson Peale with mastodon bones in his museum on FDCs of USA from 1955 | |
In 1799, Thomas Jefferson formally introduced the name “Mastodon” in a paper published in the Transactions of the American Philosophical Society. Drawing on classical Greek, he combined mastos (“breast”) and odon (“tooth”) to describe the distinctive conical projections on the animal’s molars, which he believed resembled breast-like forms. These unusual teeth clearly distinguished the creature from modern elephants, whose grinding molars were structured differently.
![]() |
![]() |
| Mastodon teeth versus mammoth on stamps of Slovenia (2018) and Tunisia (1982), MiNr. 1297 and 1034; Scott 1263 and 809F, respectively. | |
Mastodons were browsers - their teeth have cusps that help chop up branches and tough woody plants.
Mammoths and Elephants have broad, flatter teeth - for grinding up grass.
The Megalonyx Paper (1796–1799)
In 1796, Colonel John Stuart, a prominent Virginia figure, sent Jefferson large fossil bones discovered in western Virginia (now West Virginia), from a cave in Greenbrier County. Jefferson studied them closely, eager to learn more about North America’s prehistoric fauna. In March 1797, shortly after becoming Vice President and upon being elected president of the American Philosophical Society, Jefferson presented a paper titled:"A Memorial of the Discovery of Certain Bones of a Quadruped of the Clawed Kind in the Western Part of Virginia".
In this paper, Jefferson interpreted the fossils as belonging to a gigantic lion-like carnivore and named the creature Megalonyx, meaning “giant claw,” in reference to its massive claws. Using the anatomical account of the African lion by the French anatomist Daubenton for comparison, Jefferson estimated that the Megalonyx weighed more than three times the weight of the lion. This presentation is often considered the formal beginning of vertebrate paleontology in North America, marking the first detailed description of a North American fossil mammal. Notably, it is also the only formal scientific publication Jefferson ever wrote specifically on paleontology, though he continued to study fossils extensively through correspondence, collections, and other writings.
![]() |
| Eremotherium carolinensis on stamp of el Salvador 2014, MiNr.: 1293, Scott: 459. |
![]() |
| Eremotherium laurillardi on stamp of Brazil 2014, MiNr.: 4181, Scott: 3285d. |
In 1822, Wistar proposed the species name Megalonyx jeffersonii in Jefferson’s honor.
Megalonyx jeffersonii was a large herbivorous ground sloth that lived during the Pleistocene epoch. Adults could reach up to 10 feet (about 3 meters) in length and had massive claws, likely used for pulling down branches and for defense.
Despite Jefferson’s initial belief that it was a fearsome predator, Megalonyx was a slow-moving browser of forests and woodlands, an impressive example of North America’s Ice Age megafauna.Today, the Megalonyx bones described by Thomas Jefferson are preserved in the collections of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University. They were transferred there in the mid-19th century by the American Philosophical Society after the Society withdrew from maintaining natural history collections.
At a fossil site in Ecuador, at least 22 giant ground sloths (Eremotherium laurillardi) were found preserved together. Scientists believe they gathered at a shallow waterhole, and the buildup of feces and contaminated water may have caused disease or poisoning, leading to their deaths. This gives a rare glimpse into the risks faced by large herbivores in prehistoric ecosystems.
![]() |
|
| Georges Cuvier and Megatherium and FDC of France from 1969, Megatherium's stamp from Argentina 2001 on a circulated cover posted in 2008. | |
Public Criticism and the “Mastodon Room” (1808)
![]() |
![]() |
| The White House on stamp of USA 1992 MiNr.: 2213, Scott: 2609. | Thomas Jefferson on stamp of USA 1938 MiNr.: 414, Scott: 807. |
Legacy and Scientific Significance
Jefferson stood at a pivotal moment in the history of natural science. His firm conviction that extinction was impossible placed him at odds with emerging European thinkers, particularly Georges Cuvier, whose comparative anatomical studies were beginning to demonstrate that entire species had vanished from the earth. Yet Jefferson’s error was not born of ignorance, but of Enlightenment philosophy, a belief in a rational and balanced natural order in which no species would be permanently lost. Paradoxically, by promoting careful fossil collection, encouraging anatomical comparison, and presenting the first formal scientific description of a North American fossil vertebrate, he helped build the very scientific framework that would ultimately prove his own theory wrong.![]() |
| Mount Rushmore National Memorial on "Plant for a more beautiful America" stamp of USA 1966 MiNr.: 909, Scott: 1318. |
Paleontologists such as Frederic A. Lucas, then Curator‑in‑Chief of the U.S. National Museum, and Henry Fairfield Osborn, at the time Curator of Vertebrate Paleontology at the American Museum of Natural History, described Jefferson as having founded American vertebrate paleontology and regarded him as the discipline’s earliest guiding figure.
They crediting him with:
- Refuting Buffon’s degeneracy theory
- Encouraging systematic fossil collection
- Promoting stratigraphic awareness in excavation
- Presenting the first scientific paper on a North American fossil vertebrate
Some argue that his refusal to accept extinction limits his scientific legacy. Nevertheless, Jefferson’s greatest contribution may have been institutional and cultural. As President, statesman, and leader of the American Philosophical Society, he lent prestige and legitimacy to the study of fossils. In a young republic still defining its intellectual identity, his public engagement with natural history elevated palaeontology from curiosity to respectable scientific inquiry. Through argument, collection, sponsorship of expeditions, and institutional leadership, Jefferson helped lay the foundations of vertebrate palaeontology in North America.
![]() |
![]() |
|
President Thomas Jefferson on FDC of USA 1968. |
President Thomas Jefferson on FDC of USA 1986, with Monticello shown on the cachet beneath his portrait. |
Thomas Jefferson in Philately
Many postage stamps and postmarks with Thomas Jefferson were issued in the USA and other countries aroud the world. Only stamps of Thomas Jefferson on a neutral background are listed below. Other stamps, such as "Civil War" or "Declaration of Independence" are skipped as irrelevant to the topic of Paleontology.
Stamps of the USA
Note:
- Stamp issue date of some old USA stamps are different in MICHEL and Scott catalogs. In this case, the Scott Catalog dates are used in the table below.
| 14.031856 "Thomas Jefferson" | 1857 "Thomas Jefferson" | 19.08.1861 "Thomas Jefferson" |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| 13.03.1870 "Presidents" | 22.02.1890 "Presidents and other famous personalities", part of multi-year (1890-1893) definitive set | 01.01.1894 "Presidents and other famous personalities" |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| 23.03.1903 "Presidents and other famous personalities", part of multi-year (1902-1908) definitive set | 21.04.1904 "Louisiana Purchase Exposition" | 15.01.1923 "Personalities and Landscapes" |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| 01.05.1929 "Personalities and Landscapes" | 16.06.1938 "Presidents of USA" | 15.09.1954 "Liberty issue" |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| 12.01.1968 "Famous Americans" | 22.05.1986 "AMERIPEX'86, International Stamp Show - Presidents of the United States" | 03.04.1993 "Great Americans", part of big multi-year (1986-1994) definitive set |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Confederate States of America (1861-1865), issued during Civil War
| 08.11.1861 definitive issue 1 | 25.07.1862 definitive issue 2 | 1862 reprint |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Some other stamps related to Thomas Jefferson: Mount Rushmore National Memorial, Jefferson Memorial, Virginia’s Rotunda, issued in USA.
- Mount Rushmore National Memorial is a sculpture carved into the granite face of Mount Rushmore, a granite batholith in the Black Hills in Keystone, South Dakota, United States. Sculpted by Danish-American Gutzon Borglum and his son, Lincoln Borglum, Mount Rushmore features 60-foot (18 m) sculptures of the heads of four United States presidents, including Thomas Jefferson.
- The Thomas Jefferson Memorial is a presidential memorial in Washington, D.C., dedicated to Thomas Jefferson (1743–1826), built in Washington, D.C. between 1939 and 1943 under the sponsorship of President Franklin D. Roosevelt. The bronze statue of Jefferson was added in 1947.
- Virginia’s Rotunda - designed by the University’s founder, Thomas Jefferson, the Rotunda is the centerpiece of the Academical Village. Modeled after the Pantheon in Rome, it was designed to house the library and be flanked on either side by faculty pavilions, interspersed with student rooms. The University was established in 1819. Jefferson presented his plans for the Rotunda to the Board of Visitors in 1821, and it was still under construction, plagued by delays and problems, when Jefferson died in 1826.
| Mount Rushmore National Memorial | ||
| 11.08.1952 "25th anniversary of the dedication of the Mount Rushmore National Memorial" | 02.01.1974 "Mount Rushmore" (airmail) | 29.03.1991 "Flag over Mount Rushmore National Memorial" (coil stamp) |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| 06.06.2008 "American landmarks" (Priority and Express Mail) | ||
![]() |
||
| Jefferson memorial | ||
| 05.10.1966 "Beautification of America" (part of "Plant for a more beautiful America” campaign, initialized by President Lyndon B. Johnson and his wife.) | 14.12.1973 "Jefferson memorial and Signature"
(available with various perforation combinations. Scott 1510a-f) |
30.06.2002 "Jefferson memorial and Capitol Dome" (Priority and Express Mail, self-adhesive stamps) |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| Virginia’s Rotunda | ||
| 04.06.1979 "American Architecture" | ||
![]() |
||
There are many postal stationeries with portraits and profiles of Thomas Jefferson issued in USA in the second half of 1800s and beginning of 1900s
| Imrinted stamps from USA's postal stationeries related to Thomas Jefferson | ||
| USA, 18xx standart | USA, 18xx standart | USA, 1989 "Jefferson memorial" |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Commemorative postmarks and meter frankings of USA related to Thomas Jefferson
Legend is here| 13.04.1973 "Thomas Jefferson, Presidential Birthplace Station" [Sp] | ||
![]() |
Some international postage stamps related to Thomas Jefferson
Undesired stamps are on the gray background.| Andorra, 13.04.1973 | Dominica, 17.11.1989 | Ivory Coast, 27.11.1976 |
| "Thomas Jefferson, Presidential Birthplace Station" | "200th anniversary of American presidency" | "200th anniversary of American independence" |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| Romania, 25.01.1976 | Seychelles, 21.12.1976 | |
| "200th anniversary of American independence" | "200th anniversary of American independence" | |
![]() |
![]() |
|



































































